top of page
Search

It Takes an Island: Building Climate Resilience Together

2 hours ago
7 min read

Emma Bordi, City of Portland Resilience Fellow, discusses how Peaks Island is building climate resilience through community action, and what Portland can learn from it.


Peaks Island is not just jurisdictionally part of Portland, but also an important part of the city’s cultural identity. Just a 20-minute ferry ride away, the island is close enough for residents to commute comfortably back and forth, while also attracting tourists during the warmer months.


Originally inhabited by the Wabanaki Nation for at least 11,000 years, the island was later settled by Europeans, who permanently displaced its Native inhabitants.


Since then, the island has been renamed many times. From Pond, to Michael’s, to Munjoy’s - before finally settling on the name Peaks Island by 1741. The island became a very popular tourist destination in the 19th and 20th centuries, known as the “Coney Island of Maine.” From 1906 through 1948, there was also a strong military presence, especially during World War II. The Great Depression caused the foreclosure of many properties on the island, and many families in need were sent to live in those foreclosed properties during the 1940s and 1950s. By the 1970s, the island started attracting people due to its lower cost of real estate and its appeal as a place for family vacation homes. By the 2000s, home prices were rising fast on the island, coinciding with an increase in tourism. Today, it is the most populous island in Casco Bay, with more than 900 year-round residents and a median age of 62, higher than both the state and national averages. Following an independence movement in the 2000s, the Peaks Island Council (PIC) was established in 2007 to represent the island in matters of local governance in Portland.


As an AmeriCorps Resilience Corps fellow with the City of Portland’s Sustainability Office, I have been able to observe and work closely with the Peaks Island Council (PIC) and its committees, such as the Peaks Environmental Action Team (PEAT) and the Environment and Sustainability subcommittee.


My first experience on Peaks Island was at the beginning of my service term, in early February, when the island was covered in snow at a PIC meeting. There, I met Kim Peaslee from PEAT, who would later become a key collaborator in developing further climate initiatives on Peaks. Right away, I was amazed by the strong community presence on the island and hoped I would have more opportunities to return.


Organic Landcare Conference
Organic Landcare Conference

Soon after that meeting, I came back in the spring to help plan an organic landcare conference, which covered both the use of pesticides on lawns and our new program, Grow Wild, which aims to restore native habitat in urban environments. It was a rainy day and attendance was relatively low, but there was some thought-provoking discussion at the conference, as well as a growing interest on my part on the island and its tight-knit, passionate community.


I was invited to return to the island to record its composting process. A scrappy duo of residents, Owen and Will, were determined to find a way for the island to take part in the free composting drop-off sites available throughout Portland. Soon, two composting drop-off sites were established on the island, and they managed to gather a group of volunteers to help transport all the bins to the truck, using a simple ramp, and then drive the truck to Portland on the ferry.


Composting drop off volunteers
Composting drop off volunteers

Their ambition for composting on the island did not stop there.


Their goal was for the island to become as self-sufficient as possible by establishing a composting site of its own.


They were extremely resourceful; they collected horse manure from a stable on the island and added it to the compost pile, helping to enrich the future soil. Both were trained through the Maine Compost School, and their skills are put to the test with these compost piles.




Besides the composting effort, the island has been very active in pursuing other sustainability initiatives, like the “clothesline craze” promoted by another island group, Peaks Island Tax and Energy Assistance (PITEA). This initiative encourages residents to hang their clothes to dry instead of using a dryer. This group has also been working hard to help the island transition to renewable energy and become more energy self-sufficient. 


As I learned, the island has many sustainability initiatives in progress, driven by strong-willed individuals who are determined to make it a more independent and climate-resilient place to live. Still, Kim Peaslee, a longtime Peaks Island resident, co-President of PEAT, and a member of the PIC Environment and Sustainability subcommittee, told me that she wished there was a more unified front to lead these climate resiliency efforts on the island. We soon started working together with the objective of bringing people together to discuss these efforts, with the longer-term goal of developing their own climate action plan.


Our idea was to spark the conversations that could eventually lead to such a plan – and we started planning a climate resilience conference for the island in the early fall. 


It took months of preparation, but we eventually put together a lineup of speakers and organizations, including representatives from the Gulf of Maine Research Institute (GMRI), Island Institute, and FB Environmental. The latter two have worked incredibly closely with Peaks Islanders. Island Institute has examined erosion on the island, including at Ferry Beach, which I had the pleasure of visiting with a group led by ShoreCorps Steward Emma Polhemus. 


ShoreCorps Steward Emma Polhemus leading an erosion assessment on Ferry Beach, Peaks Island
ShoreCorps Steward Emma Polhemus leading an erosion assessment on Ferry Beach, Peaks Island

FB Environmental has worked closely with island residents, publishing the Peaks Island: Environmental, Cultural and Issues Assessment in 2023, which also provided much of the historical background for this article. In 2024, together with PIC, the organization also helped conduct a community survey to identify which topics residents wanted to explore in workshops. Climate change, education, and mental health were the primary topics chosen by the community.


Kim and I wanted to build on this existing interest and carry it into our conference. After much promotion on the island, more than 30 islanders showed up on the big day.


The conference was full of passionate discussions and great questions from residents, and some islanders staying until the very end.


It felt like a culmination of all my work with the island and throughout my term of service. In the morning, GMRI, Island Institute, and FB Environmental gave presentations. At lunch, Will and Owen from the composting team joined residents for a discussion about their work. In the afternoon, PITEA, Carrie Finch (a landscaper and gardener who had also participated in the first organic landcare conference I helped organize), and the Community Emergency Response Team were present. Kim and FB Environmental also shared information about erosion on the island.


Second Peaks Island Conference
Second Peaks Island Conference
Afternoon activities at second Peaks Island Conference
Afternoon activities at second Peaks Island Conference

The familiarity and sense of community in the room during the conference were palpable. All hands were on deck to help us set up, clean up, and pick up guest speakers at the ferry landing. That familiarity also made it possible to have some uncomfortable but nevertheless important conversations during the event. It proved particularly useful in the afternoon, as people split into four groups to discuss possible solutions to challenges such as communication gaps, erosion, and energy self-sufficiency.


All this work on Peaks has really left me feeling hopeful about how community and climate resilience can be brought together. Thanks to the efforts of just a few people, so many things have happened on the island this past year that will help build a brighter future for the community. I am hopeful that a more unified approach will develop, and that, if a climate action plan is created, the lessons learned could be applied to other individual neighborhoods in Portland. 


It has truly been a pleasure to witness and support these efforts on Peaks, and I am excited for their future. The same kind of community energy is definitely present in mainland Portland, but because the city is much larger and more spread out, it may make sense to organize these efforts one neighborhood at a time. As the Director of the Portland Sustainability Office, Troy Moon, often says, our approach should be "city-supported, community-led." Peaks Island is a great example of what this can look like in practice. The city can provide resources, connections, and support; but it is ultimately the people who know their neighborhoods best and can identify the needs and drive change. As Peaks Island demonstrated, we need to really get to know our neighbors if we want to be better prepared for the future.


Community-led initiatives might not be the only key to solving the climate crisis, but they will definitely play a big role in the future. What this experience has taught me is that building climate resilience starts with building relationships. It takes people who know their neighbors, care about their community, and are willing to roll up their sleeves and get things done. If there is one main thing that Peaks Island has shown me, it is that meaningful change doesn't always start with a big plan. Sometimes, it starts with a few people coming together and deciding to try.


About Emma


Emma is from Rome, Italy, and grew up in an Italian American household. She earned her bachelor’s degree in Political Science and International Relations from Sapienza University in Rome and then went on to receive her master's degree in Policies for Global Security: Environment, Energy, and Conflicts at Roma Tre University. During her studies, she participated in two study abroad programs: one in Portugal for her bachelor’s and one in Hungary for her master’s. While in Portugal, she interned with Almargem, an environmental nonprofit focused on protecting the Portuguese coastal region of the Algarve, in the south of the country. Here, she learned to apply her passion for environmental protection and community work. In her free time, Emma enjoys volunteering on environmental and community issues, including teaching Italian to refugees, building playgrounds and organizing activities for children in refugee centers, learning sustainable farming practices, and taking part in hunger relief programs for unhoused people. Beyond her volunteer work, she also loves to travel, hike, and listen to audiobooks and podcasts. As a Resilience Corps Fellow, Emma is excited to combine her passion and knowledge for community work and environmental sustainability and learn as much as possible from the Portland community.

 
 
 

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.
VM_logo_vertical_negative_web_transparent.png
Americorps_Seconday-logo_White.png
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
bottom of page